UYLLII

Blog › Game design

Game design

Why Diggings has no energy timer, and what I put in its place

By David3 min read
Diggings feature graphic

When I first played a finished build of Diggings properly, I liked it. Two simple mechanics, panning and swinging a pick, and I wanted another go. Then I had a worse thought: I can see people playing this for a day or two, finishing it and being done.

A few days before, I'd finished an early build in under an hour, and "the game is too short" was the first note I wrote down. So I had two problems, and one tempting fix.

The usual answer is energy

Energy is the standard tool. Every action costs a point, the points refill over hours, and you wait or pay. It does stretch a game over many days. It also does three things I didn't want:

In Diggings every day played is also another evening, and an evening is where the optional video offers happen. Blocking play blocks that too. But the first two reasons were enough. I decided there would be no energy, and that nothing would ever stop a player starting a season.

A season is about twenty minutes. That is already a natural place to put the phone down, so a timer wasn't needed to give people somewhere to stop.

What went in instead

The aim was reasons to come back tomorrow, never a lock on today.

A rested bonus. The first season you start on each calendar day begins "well rested": three extra washes or swings a day for that whole season. Later seasons that day play as normal, with no penalty and no nagging. It rewards spreading play over days without blocking any of it. The game also remembers the last date it granted the bonus, so winding the phone's clock back doesn't grant it again.

A daily goal. One a day, picked from the date and from what you can actually do at the place you're playing: land some clean washes, move upstream, dig deeper, find a nugget, win a season. It pays into your savings when it's done, and it's sized to about a third of a won season so it's a real part of a session, not a free tap. Goals done on consecutive days build a streak that adds 10% to the reward for each day, up to 60%. Miss a day and the streak resets to zero, and the next goal starts it again with no punishment.

More to buy over weeks. Tools go up eight levels, each dearer than the last. Equipment is bought in small steps.

Licences. A new claim needs a licence, bought once with your savings, as well as a won season at the place before it.

Grades. Buy the same claim again at a higher grade and you get richer ground and steeper fees. There's no top grade, so the end of the career is open: past the last place the claims go deeper, the fees climb and there's a record to beat.

A second track of creeks. There was a gap: only one place to pan, and I wanted at least two. Panning became a track of its own, Forest Creek, then Reedy Creek with faster water and bigger nuggets, then the wide Ovens River with a heavy bed. Each pays on a level with the pick place of its tier, with its own look and its own finds.

Did it work?

I can't say yet. Whether any of this keeps a person coming back is a question for real players, and Diggings hasn't had many players yet. What I can measure is length. With these changes, my scripted players take roughly 20 to 33 hours to buy everything at grade I (counting a day as about 45 seconds), where it had been about 8 hours, and then the grades go on. A rested bonus and a daily goal don't show up in those numbers at all, so they're extra.

What I'll watch after launch is whether people come back on a second and third day. If they don't, the answer won't be a timer.